The More I Work, The More Work I Get – How to Avoid the Performance Punishment Trap

I used to think working harder was the answer. When my inbox overflowed, I’d stay late. When deadlines piled up, I’d skip lunch. When colleagues asked for help, I’d say yes — every time. I believed that if I just did more, I’d eventually earn respect, recognition, and, most importantly, relief. Instead, I got more work. Always more!!

It wasn’t until I hit a breaking point — exhausted, irritable, and still drowning in tasks — that I realized: working harder wasn’t solving the problem. It was fueling it.

This isn’t just my story. It’s the story of countless professionals who’ve fallen into what I now call the “Performance Punishment Trap”. The trap isn’t about laziness or poor time management. It’s about a systemic misalignment between effort and value — and how organizations, often unintentionally, reward visibility over sustainability.

How It Happens

When you consistently deliver under pressure, you become the go-to person. Not because you’re the most skilled (though you may be) but because you’re reliable. You show up. You meet deadlines. You don’t complain. And in a world where visibility equals credibility, that makes you indispensable. But here’s the cruel irony: being indispensable doesn’t mean you’re protected. It means you’re targeted.

I saw this clearly when I managed a small team early in my career. One team member, Sarah, always finished her reports early, double-checked everyone’s work, and never said no to an extra request. Within six months, she was handling three roles: her own, one vacant position, and half of another colleague’s workload. She was praised in meetings. Promoted—sort of. Her title changed. Her salary didn’t. And her burnout became visible in the dark circles under her eyes and the way she stopped laughing at team lunches.

The organization didn’t intend to exploit her. They simply didn’t notice the imbalance. They saw output, not exhaustion. And Sarah, conditioned by years of being told “hard work pays off,” didn’t know how to set boundaries without feeling guilty.

How Do You Break Free?

Start by shifting your metric of success. Stop measuring your worth by the number of tasks completed and start measuring it by the impact you create and the boundaries you protect.

In my own case, I began tracking not just what I did, but what I didn’t do. Every time someone asked me to take on something new, I paused. Not to say no, but to ask: “What should I deprioritize to make room for this?” That simple question forced conversations I’d been avoiding. It turned vague requests into concrete trade-offs.

One Tuesday, a senior director asked me to lead a new client onboarding project on top of my existing responsibilities. Instead of saying yes immediately, I said, “I’d be happy to help. Right now, I’m managing the Q4 compliance review and the vendor contract renegotiation. If I take this on, one of those will need to shift timelines. Which one would you prefer I adjust?”

The silence was awkward. Then she said, “Actually, let me check with the legal team first. Maybe they can handle it.”

It was the first time I’d ever used that question and it worked. Not because I was rude, but because I forced clarity. I stopped being a passive receptacle for work and became a strategic partner in resource allocation.

This doesn’t mean saying no to everything. It means saying “not now” or “not without adjustment” with intention.

Stop Doing Work That Doesn’t Require Your Unique Skills

I once spent three hours formatting a presentation deck that a junior colleague could have done in 30 minutes. Why? Because I thought it would look better if I did it. And because I didn’t want to “bother” them. The result? I was exhausted, they felt underutilized, and the deck was no better than it would have been otherwise.

I started asking myself: “If I weren’t here, who else could do this?” If the answer is “anyone with basic training,” then delegate — not just assign, but coach. Give context. Set expectations. Follow up. Delegation isn’t dumping; it’s developing. And when done well, it reduces your load while building capacity in others.

I began doing this with my team. I took one recurring task I hated monthly expense report reconciliation and trained a new hire to own it. I created a one-page guide, walked through it twice, and then stepped back. The first month, there were errors. The second, fewer. By the third, it was flawless. And suddenly, I had six hours a month back not just for more work, but for strategic thinking, mentoring, and rest.

Unlearn The Guilt.

We’ve been conditioned to believe that saying no is selfish, that resting is lazy, that taking time off is a sign of weakness. But the truth is, sustainable performance requires space. Not just physical space, mental and emotional space too.

I started scheduling “non-negotiables” into my calendar: a 45-minute walk every afternoon, Friday afternoons blocked for reflection, and Sunday evenings free from emails. At first, I felt guilty. I checked my phone. I worried I’d miss something. But the world didn’t end. In fact, my clarity improved. My decisions got sharper. My team started modeling the same behavior.

A few months in, one of my direct reports told me, “I used to think you were just really good at multitasking. Now I realize you’re really good at choosing what matters.”

That was the moment I knew I was changing the game — not just for myself, but for the culture around me.

Working harder won’t get you out of the Performance Punishment Trap. Working smarter will. And working smarter means protecting your time as fiercely as you protect your results.

  • It means having the courage to say, “I can’t do this unless something else moves.”
  • It means trusting others to do things differently, even if not perfectly.
  • It means resting without apology.

The Solution – Working Smarter

Break Free from Performance Punishment

The more you work, the more work you get — not because you’re failing, but because the system is broken. You’re not the problem. You’re the solution.

Start today. Pick one task you’ve been doing out of habit, not necessity. Delegate it. Or delete it. Or delay it. Then notice what happens.

The work won’t disappear. But you will start to reclaim your energy, your agency, and your life.

And that’s the only metric that truly matters.

Scroll to Top
Copy link